GM bid to block ignition-switch suits rejected by Supreme Court

on Apr25

In 2015, a U.S. bankruptcy judge ruled that GM was shielded from liability over its pre-bankruptcy actions. The 2nd Circuit reversed that ruling. Photo credit: Getty Images/Stockphoto

UPDATED: 4/24/17 4:15 pm ET – adds details, stock close

WASHINGTON — General Motors’ bid to block hundreds of lawsuits, potentially worth billions of dollars, over a deadly ignition-switch defect broke down on Monday when the U.S. Supreme Court refused to hear its appeal claiming the suits were barred by the automaker’s 2009 bankruptcy.

The justices declined to review a 2016 ruling by the New York-based 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals that rejected GM’s bid to block customer lawsuits related to crashes and diminished vehicle value because the plaintiffs had not been properly notified of the defect prior to the bankruptcy filing. 

The case involved a faulty ignition switch in GM vehicles linked to 124 deaths and 275 injuries. The switch could slip out of place, causing engine stalls while driving and cutting power to critical brakes, steering and air bag systems.

GM spokesman Jim Cain said in a statement the denial of the appeal “was not a decision on the merits, and it’s likely that the issues we raised will have to be addressed in the future in other venues because the Second Circuit’s decision departed substantially from well-settled bankruptcy law.”

The court’s action allows lawsuits to proceed over pre-bankruptcy death, injury, economic loss and used-car economic losses.

“Hundreds of death and injury cases have been frozen in place for years as GM wrongly tried to hide behind a fake bankruptcy,” Robert Hilliard, lead counsel for the plaintiffs, said in a statement. “Now, GM can hide no more.”

‘Small risk’

The Supreme Court’s decision creates a small risk that GM will have to reach a legal settlement that could interfere with paying out its dividend or buying back stock, said David Whiston, a Morningstar Inc. analyst.

“The market would not like that at all, but I think that’s a very small risk,” Whiston said by phone. “I’d rather they settle this sooner, just to get the overhang off the stock.”

GM shares rose 0.5 percent on Monday to close at $33.91.

GM’s Cain said that “as a practical matter, this doesn’t change the landscape much in terms of the GM litigation. The plaintiffs must still establish their right to assert successor liability claims. From there, (they) still have to prove those claims have merit.”

The defect prompted GM to begin recalling 2.6 million vehicles in 2014. It has already paid roughly $2.5 billion in criminal and civil penalties and settlements and legal fees in connection with the switch. The company previously acknowledged that some of its employees knew about the switch defect for years before a recall was initiated.

Reversed ruling

In 2015, a U.S. bankruptcy judge ruled that GM was shielded from liability over its pre-bankruptcy actions. The 2nd Circuit reversed that ruling. Since the plaintiffs were not properly notified of the defect or bankruptcy filing, barring them from suing GM would violate their constitutional rights to due process, the court found.

“Due process applies even in a company’s moment of crisis,” the appeals court stated.

That ruling affected injury and death cases stemming from pre-bankruptcy crashes, as well as claims from customers who said their vehicles lost value as a result of the ignition switch and recalls involving other parts. The claims could be worth up to $10 billion, according to court papers.

GM has disputed the plaintiffs lawyers’ estimate that it faces as much as $10 billion in liabilities.

The plaintiffs have said GM moved too slowly to recall vehicles with the faulty ignition switches. While GM has said top executives didn’t know the ignition switch was a persistent problem, the company admitted in a Justice Department settlement that it knew about the defect by 2005 and concealed it from regulators from 2012 to 2014.

GM CEO Mary Barra set up a compensation fund led by Kenneth Feinberg to deal with litigation related to the ignition switches in 2014. GM paid out on less than 10 percent of 4,343 claims submitted for a total of $594 million in settlements.

GM, supported by the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and the National Association of Manufacturers, said under the federal bankruptcy code, its 2009 bankruptcy sale to a new government-owned entity made it “free and clear” of former liabilities.



Previous postFord sees strong global sales of its iconic Mustang Next postTrump's sagging poll numbers overshadow view on US economy

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *



Los Angeles Financial times


Copyright © 2020 Los Angeles Financial times

Updates via RSS
or Email